Description / Abstract:
Foreword
Tire forensics is the methodical analysis of failed tires in the
pursuit of and the identification of the cause(s) or root cause(s)
of the disablement of a tire. A combination of science, experience,
and some art goes into the research and analysis of a tire failure.
By using the laws of physics, math, chemistry, and engineering,
mixed with the expert's real-world tire background and experience
in the design, testing, and tire development and manufacturing
processes, tire forensic experts determine the most likely events
that led up to and caused the tire to fail.
Unlike a forensic pathologist analyzing a body in a criminal
case, a failed tire in a civil suit typically is considered
evidence that cannot be dissected and destructively analyzed
without agreement by all sides. The analysis by the tire expert
also may not occur until years later, with a chain of custody that
may or may not be tidy and with storage conditions that can be less
than optimal. Given these conditions, the forensic tire expert's
background, knowledge, and ability to determine pre-, during, or
post-accident damage can be crucial to determining failure
causation.
The same sidewall that will cut and tear during a curb scuff
event can impact a road hazard to bend the wheel flange backwards
and show relatively little damage on the exterior of the tire. It
takes a trained eye working in a systematic fashion to find the
unusual detail that leads to the root cause contributors to the
failure. I say "root cause" because the type of failure should not
be the end result of the investigator's work. It usually is the
beginning. The goal of the tire forensic expert is to keep digging
backwards, looking for root cause(s) and putting as much of the
tire story together as possible.
In this book, I cover the many ways that a tire can fail and how
to identify that failure. However, I will not be going into
anything but minor depth in several sections on defectively
manufactured tires. It is my opinion that an expert tire forensic
investigator looking into manufacturing or design defects requires
knowledge of not only tire failure mechanics, but also a solid
grounding in several areas such as tire manufacturing, tire
mechanics, testing, and tire design, as well as some familiarity
with quality control parameters. The total range of parameters, how
all the various pieces are supposed to fit and operate together,
and what are the correct or incorrect manufacturing details in a
tire will contain subtleties and nuances; thus, at times, only
experience can dictate the outcome. These subtleties will make each
tire its own case with particular circumstances and therefore will
be covered only generally here. However, while the tire forensic
expert is performing the inspection, he or she must always examine
the tire with an open mind, looking for all possibilities of
failure modes, including an improperly manufactured tire or a badly
designed tire.
The terms "accident sequence," "pre-accident," and
"post-accident" are used frequently in this book. Most tire
failures do not result in vehicle damage, collisions, rollovers,
and so forth. However, litigation-related tire failures tend to
involve at least some vehicle damage. By using these terms, I am
relating the tire conditions that are seen to the sequence of
events after tire disablement, whether or not vehicle damage or an
accident has occurred.